This short webinar introduces you to the Open Source Risk Project and Open Source Risk Engine (ORE). Roland Lichters, co-founder and CTO of Quaternion, walks you through ORE’s history and mission, project and analytics scope and shows how to quickly get your hands on running ORE. For more detail, please visit https://www.opensourcerisk.org.
Unsecured short-term interbank funding in the IBOR market (“InterBank Offered Rates”) has declined dramatically following the 2012 rate-fixing scandals and its integrity has been openly called into question. In July 2017, the UK’s Financial Conduct Authority declared that it would no longer persuade or compel banks to submit their interbank borrowing rates after 2021. While central bank-led working groups have been convening since 2014 to establish appropriate Alternative Reference Rates (“ARRs”) for each IBOR currency, the FCA’s triggering event has solidified the need for financial market participants to prepare for the impending cessation of IBORs. Given outstanding uncertainties in the working groups’ determination of ARRs per currency, calculating IBOR exposures and establishing a transition plan is critical in advance of 2021 while there still remains sufficient time to proactively manage the market, accounting, and legal risks. This White Paper describes Quaternion’s IBOR-related services aimed at helping financial market participants prepare for 2021:
- Evaluation of existing IBOR exposures and hedge effectiveness, including stress testing
- Portfolio compression of IBORs, while maintaining the same duration-adjusted exposure
- Quantitative support during legal renegotiations of derivative and loan documentation
- Calculation of go-forward spread and tenor adjustments to equalize ARRs and LIBORs
At the end of 2018, the financial industry has still not yet established a consensus methodology for calculation of Margin Value Adjustment (MVA) on non- centrally cleared derivatives. MVA represents the expected funding cost of initial margin over the lifetime of a trade/portfolio, and is particularly relevant today due to BCBS-IOSCO 261 – more commonly referred to as the “Swaps Margin Rules”, it requires financial entities to exchange sufficient collateral to cover potential losses over a 10-day period with 99% confidence, and is complementary to the margin typically used to settle daily mark-to-market changes (variation margin), phasing-in to cover most derivatives market participants by September 2020. MVA is the most recent valuation adjustment (“xVA”), joining similar calculations for counterparty credit risk (CVA), the funding cost of variation margin (FVA), and the cost of capital (KVA), among others. MVA is particularly difficult to calculate due to the requirements for trade sensitivities along each Monte Carlo simulation path as inputs to ISDA’s Standard Initial Margin Model (SIMM). AD provides the most efficient and robust calculation of these in-simulation sensitivities.
Quaternion sponsors an Open Source Risk User Meeting in Frankfurt on Friday 23rd November 2018 at Fleming’s Hotel, Frankfurt City, Eschenheimer Tor 2.
“The Open Source Risk Project’s objective is to provide a free/open source platform for risk analytics and XVA. ORE is based on QuantLib and grew from work developed by market professionals and academics.” (http://opensourcerisk.org)
With this first meeting we want to provide a communication platform for the ORE users in the industry and ORE’s developers, contributors and creators, to help propagating ORE’s usage and its further development.
The agenda will cover short presentations of use cases and leave sufficient room for discussing the future of ORE’s usage.
Attending the conference will be free of charge, but the number of seats is limited. If you want to join, please register on the bottom of the agenda.
The following is an indicative agenda. If you would like to share your experience with ORE, please let us know with your registration. We would be happy to rearrange the agenda.
Agenda / Speakers
|09:00-09:15||Welcome||Roland Lichters (Quaternion)|
|09:15-09:45||XVA-Valuation Project with ORE||Roland Kapl (OeBFA – Österreichische Bundesfinanzierungsagentur)|
|09:45-10:15||Understanding the Impact of Regulation on Systemic Risk with ORE||Nikolai Nowaczyk (Quaternion)||10:15-10:45||ORE in Pricing of Bermudan Swaptions: Client Experience from Model Validation||Dmitry Zaykovskiy (Deutsche Pfandbriefbank AG)|
|11:15-11:45||XVA Model Validation||Patrick Büchel (Commerzbank)|
|11:45-12:15||Structured Loan Pricing and Embedded Prepayment Options in Project Financing High Yield Markets||Oleg Kulkov (Allianz Global Investors)||12:15-12:45||Alternative Use Case for ORE: An Interactive Application for Financial Planning and Controlling||Andreas Kewenig (Aareal Bank AG)|
|14:00-14:30||Sensitivity Analysis, ISDA SIMM Benchmarking and Backtesting with RESTORE||Niall O’Sullivan (Quaternion)||14:30-15:00||ORE in Python and Java||Roland Lichters (Quaternion)|
|15:00-15:30||A precursor to ORE in Excel: Calculating the VaR using Deriscope and QuantLib||Ioannis Rigopoulos (Deriscope)||15:30-16:00||Tea/Coffee|
|17:00-17:15||Wrap up||Roland Lichters (Quaternion)|
- Andreas Boldin, Credit Suisse AG
- Roland Lichters, Quaternion Risk Management
- Andre Suess, Credit Suisse AG
- Markus Trahe, Credit Suisse AG
November 16, 2016
The tenor basis phenomenon became significant with the 2007 financial crisis and has altered the traditional way of one-curve pricing and risk management to a multi-curve phenomenon. The stochastic nature of basis spreads between curves particularly poses a challenge for forward looking applications like XVA or real world measure exposure analytics. This paper presents a Two- factor Gaussian approach for modelling multiple fixing curves and basis spreads in the risk neutral and spot measure, shows the impact on basis swap exposure, investigates the correlation structure and discusses the pros and cons of interpreting as a spread or multi curve model respectively.
Quaternion recently sponsored a September 14th Risk.net webinar discussion on the evolution of XVAs. Participants included Scott Sobolewski (Principal Consultant at Quaternion), Yann Coatanlem (MD, Head of Multi-Asset Quantitative Analysis at Citigroup,
Massimo Morini (Head of Interest Rate and Credit Models, Banca IMI), and Peter Zeitsch (Solution Architect at Calypso Technology).
The list of valuation adjustments banks must apply when pricing a derivative has grown exponentially and given rise to an alphabet soup of new valuation adjustments. The term XVAs has been coined to describe the entire family, namely funding valuation adjustment (FVA), capital valuation adjustment (KVA), and now, margin valuation adjustment (MVA). The sheer volume of these adjustments coupled with the impact on profitability has led banks to compute the capital required to support them through the life of the trade. This has considerably increased the computational complexity as well as placed demands for real time calculation of all of this information. Needless to say, dealers attempting to manage their XVAs are finding the process extremely challenging and a few have joined-up in an effort to curb their XVAs, under the banner of optimisation and trade compression.
Discussion topics included:
- What is MVA and how does it interact with the other XVAs?
- How complex is MVA, relative to other adjustments?
- In practical terms, where is the industry on MVA at this point?
- Do you expect MVA to follow the same evolutionary path that we’ve seen for other XVAs?
- Interaction between MVA, KVA, CVA, DVA, FVA
- Rank order of the different XVAs, once IM regime has been fully implemented
- What are the key regulations that will determine the correct MVA/XVA treatment for a trade?
- What are the practical / implementation challenges?
- Given all of this, what timeline is likely for MVA to start showing up in pricing?
- How much pricing dispersion is it likely to produce?
- Can MVA already be seen for cleared trades with CCPs?
- Accounting treatment for MVA (IFRS 9, 13)
- What does the blending / blurring of XVAs mean for the way they are managed? What is the right organisational structure?
Listen to the webinar here.
Scott Sobolewski, a Principal Consultant in our Boston office, recently published an article in Treasury & Risk Magazine titled “How Do Dealer Banks Price Derivative Products?”. The article helps corporate treasurers, asset managers, and other end-users of over-the-counter (OTC) derivatives understand the various components of bank regulatory and capital charges currently built into dealer pricing. Most users have grown comfortable with concepts like CVA and FVA, though newer valuation adjustments for initial margin (MVA) and regulatory capital (KVA), as well as Basel’s new initial margin rule taking effect on September 1, 2016, make it more important than ever to keep pace with new regulation. The market environment necessitates that risk managers at large financial institutions and end-user treasury functions understand how bank pricing has evolved in the wake of Dodd Frank and Basel III, not only for regulatory compliance exercises like reporting or stress testing, but for proactive risk management. By facilitating increased understanding on both sides of a derivatives trade, Quaternion hopes to increase liquidity within the shrinking uncleared OTC derivative market and reduce overall systemic risk across the financial system.
Quaternion sponsored a QuantLib User Meeting at the Chartered Accountants’ Hall, One Moorgate Place, London EC2R 6EA on Tuesday 12th July 2016.
“The QuantLib project is aimed at providing a comprehensive software framework for quantitative finance. QuantLib is a free/open-source library for modeling, trading, and risk management in real-life. […] Appreciated by quantitative analysts and developers, it is intended for academics and practitioners alike, eventually promoting a stronger interaction between them.” (http://quantlib.org)
With this meeting we want to provide a communication platform for both QuantLib users in the industry and QuantLib’s developers, contributors and creators, to help propagating QuantLib’s usage. This meeting continues a tradition of annual user forums and brings this event back to London where the first event of this type was held on January 18th, 2011.
Final Agenda / Speakers
|09:00-09:15||Welcome||Roland Lichters (Quaternion)|
|09:15-10:15||The abcd of Interest Rate Basis Spreads||Luigi Ballabio (StatPro) and Ferdinando Ametrano (Banca IMI)|
|10:15-11:00||Open Risk Engine||Peter Caspers, Niall O’Sullivan and Roland Lichters (Quaternion)|
|11:30-12:15||Reposit 1.8 and the Future of Spreadsheet Addins||Eric Ehlers (Reposit)|
|12:15-12:45||A simple application of the QuantLib observer pattern – Multi-Curve-Sensitivities||Michael von den Driesch (IKB)|
|13:30-14:15||QuantLibAdjoint News||Alexander Sokol (CompatibL)|
|14:15-15:00||A sound modelling and backtesting framework for forecasting initial margin requirements||Daniel Aziz (Credit Suisse)|
|15:30-16:15||Calibration using Neural Networks||Andres Hernandez (IBM)|
|16:15-16:45||Multi-Curve Convexity||Sebastian Schlenkrich (d-fine)|
|16:45-17:00||Wrap up||Roland Lichters (Quaternion)|
The conference was held in the Auditorium and Atrium of the prestigious Chartered Accountants’ Hall at the Institute of Chartered Accountants, One Moorgate Place, London EC2R 6EA, details of which can be found here.
The location is easily accessible from Moorgate and Bank tube stations as can be seen here.
The presentations can be downloaded shortly from the QuantLib web site here.
A top-class panel of risk experts from banks, universities and audit companies discussed the current state and the future of standard approaches, risk factor models, simulation and regulation on May 3rd 2016 in Frankfurt.
While a South Korean delegation was getting into the mood for the annual meeting of the Asian Development Bank at the Grandhotel Hessischer Hof, many risk managers from banks and other companies arrived in the room next door. The setting was perfect for the eclectic mix of experts, who maintained an interesting discussion for more than an hour. Roland Stamm, Partner at Quaternion Risk Management, was responsible for the organization of the evening and moderated the panel. The discussion was very dynamic and marked by both unanimously agreed and opposed analyses of various aspects of the status quo in risk modeling.
Roland Lichters, Roland Stamm, Donal Gallagher
Modern Derivatives Pricing and Credit Exposure Analysis: Theory and Practice of CSA and XVA Pricing, Exposure Simulation and Backtesting
The past 10 years have see an incredible change in pricing financial products, driven by the credit crisis which started in 2007 with the near bankruptcy of Bear Sterns, reaching a first climax with the implosion of the US housing market and the banking world’s downfall, and then turning into a sovereign debt crisis in Europe. A major change to have affected the landscape has been the increasing complexity in the valuation of derivatives – multi-curve pricing , various value adjustments (XVAs) using Monte Carlo simulation of markets through time , credit risk measurement and capital allocation – all based on increasingly complex mathematical and IT machinery.
Published in November 2015, Modern Derivatives Pricing and Credit Exposure Analysis is a comprehensive, practical guidebook for modern derivatives pricing and credit analysis, written with the practitioner in mind. Theoretically rigorous but focused on market practice, it provides a detailed and consistent toolkit of pricing and risk methods to cope with the increasing complexities of today’s derivatives management. The presented risk factor evolution models for six different asset classes allow efficient computation of various value adjustments (XVAs) and risk measures in a competitive and increasingly regulated environment. The text bridges the gap between the risk-neuraland real-world measure for backtesting purposes and explains different methods for speeding up XVA computation in order to allow fast calculations of margin adjustment or XVA greeks.
Written to provide sound theoretical detail with practical implementation, this book provides readers with both an overview and deep dive into valuation and risk methods applied in the industry today.
See the book at the Palgrave Macmillan website.
Part I – Discounting
- Discounting Before the Crisis
- What Changed With the Crisis
- Clearing House Pricing
- Global Discounting
- CSA Discounting
- Fair Value Hedge Accounting
Part II – Credit and Debit Value Adjustment
- Fundamentals: Unilateral and Bilateral CVA
- Single Trade CVA: Interest Rate Swaps, FX Forwards, Cross Currency Swap Flavours
Part III – Risk factor Evolution
- Monte Carlo Framework
- Interest Rates: Linear Gauss Markov Model, Stochastic Basis, CSA Discounting Revisited
- Foreign Exchange: Multi-Currency LGM, Cross Currency Basis
- Inflation: Jarrow-Yildirim and Dodgson-Kainth Models
- Equity and Commodity: One and Two-Factor Models
- Credit: Gaussian, Extended Cox-Ingersoll-Ross, Black-Karasinski and Peng-Kou Models
Part IV – XVA
- Cross Asset Scenario Generation
- Netting and Collateral
- Early Exercise and American Monte Carlo
- CVA Risk and Algorithmic Differentiation
- Funding Value Adjustment: FVA Debate, Expectation and Semi-Replication Approach, MVA
- Capital and Tax Value Adjustment: KVA by Semi-Replication, TVA
Part V – Credit Risk
- Fundamentals, Portfolio Credit Models
- Pricing Portfolio Credit Products: Synthetic CDOs, Cashflow Structures
- Credit Risk for Derivatives: Real-World Measure, SA-CCR, Internal Model Approach, CVA Capital Charge
- Backtesting: Framework, Risk-Factor Backtesting, Portfolio Backtesting
Part VI – Appendix
- The Change of Measure Toolkit
- The Feynman-Kac Connection
- The Black76 Formula
- Hull-White Model
- Linear Gauss Markov Model
- Dodgson Kainth Model
- Cox-Ingersoll Ross Model with Jumps
- Filtration Switching and the Peng-Kou Model
- Fabrizio Anfuso, Credit Suisse Securities (Europe) Limited
- Daniel Aziz, Credit Suisse Securities (Europe) Limited
- Paul Giltinan, Quaternion Risk Management
- Klearchos Loukopoulos, Credit Suisse Securities (Europe) Limited
January 15, 2016
The introduction by regulators of mandatory margining for bilateral OTCs is going to have a major impact on the derivatives market, particularly in light of the additional funding costs and liquidity requirements that large financial institutions will face. Fabrizio Anfuso, Daniel Aziz, Paul Giltinan and Klearchos Loukopoulos propose in the following a simple and consistent framework, equally applicable to non-cleared and cleared portfolios, to develop and backtest forecasting models for Initial Margin.
- Marco de Innocentis, Credit Suisse Securities (Europe) Limited
- Roland Lichters , Quaternion Risk Management
- Markus Trahe, Quaternion Risk Management
February 8, 2016
This paper describes a procedure for efficiently simulating a multi asset Heston model with an arbitrary correlation structure. Very little literature can be found on the topic (e.g. Wadman (2010) and Dimitroff et al. (2011)), the latter being very restrictive on correlation assumptions. The scheme proposed in this text is based on Andersen’s Quadratic Exponential (QE) scheme (2008) and operates with an arbitrary input correlation structure, which is partially decorrelated via a Gaussian copula approach to fit the single asset QE prerequisites. Given a long term horizon, it is shown numerically that, in the multi asset QE (MQE) scheme, all combinations of terminal correlations converge quickly to the true terminal correlations for decreasing Monte Carlo time step size, if the input correlation matrix is interpreted as the system’s instantaneous correlation matrix. Convergence of vanilla and spread option prices is investigated, in order to verify the appropriate behaviour for higher moments of the marginal and the joint distribution under MQE. Finally, the superiority of MQE vs. Taylor based schemes is shown by comparing convergence of the empirical PDF, calculated with Monte Carlo, to the “exact” function calculated via Fourier inversion.
Download the paper here.
- Donal Gallagher, Quaternion Risk Management
- James P. Gleeson, University of Limerick, Ireland
- Chris Kenyon, Lloyds Banking Group
- Roland Lichters, Quaternion Risk Management
September 15, 2009
Unlike tranches of synthetic CDOs, that depend only on the defaults of the underlying securities, tranches of cashflow CDOs also depend on the interest cash flows from the coupons of the securities. Whilst fast, accurate, (semi-)analytic methods exist for pricing synthetic CDO tranches (Hull and White 2004), no equivalent methods exist for pricing cashflow CDO tranches because of their dependence on both principal and interest waterfalls. We introduce an analytical approximation that renders cashflow CDOs amenable to (semi-)analytic pricing. The complication of needing the joint distribution of interest and outstanding notional is reduced to needing only their marginal distributions. We show that our analytic approximation is globally valid with bounded errors that are small in most cases. Furthermore, our approach can be extended to more detailed structural features such as interest coverage tests and over-collateralization tests. We present results from realistic cashflow CDO examples.
Wall Street Meets FinTech: Interactive Visualization of Simulations of Systemic Financial Market Risk Conditional on Policy Interventions was the subject of a recent demo at Columbia University’s Data Science Day where Quaternion Risk Management (QRM) announced a new research partnership with the faculty of Columbia University in New York. The event was designed to foster collaboration between innovators in academia and industry through demos and lightning talks by Columbia University researchers presenting their latest work in data science. “This partnership launches the inaugural collaboration within the ‘Financial Risk Analytics and Regulation Innovation Lab’ at Columbia’s School of Professional Studies,” says Sharyn O’Halloran (George Blumenthal Professor of Political Economics and Professor of International and Public Affairs).
The authors of “Modern Derivatives Pricing and Credit Exposure Analysis” – Roland Lichters, Roland Stamm and Donal Gallagher, all Partners of Quaternion Risk Management, launched their book at a well attended event run by QRM at The Marriott in Canary Wharf on Monday 29th February 2016.
The event was kicked off with a Panel discussion by a selection of well known industry figures, moderated by Ms. Laura Noonan, Investment Banking Correspondent of the Financial Times. The Panel included:
- Dr. Fabrizio Anfuso – Head of Collateralized Exposure Modelling at Credit Suisse
- Dr. Ronnie Barnes – Principal at Cornerstone Research
- Dr. Paul Burnett – Global Head of Traded Risk Analytics at HSBC
- Dr. Giovanni Cesari – XVA Analytics Ltd.
- Dr. Andrew Green – Head of CVA/FVA Quantitative Research at Lloyds Banking Group
- Mr. Stéphane Boivin – Senior Policy Expert, European Banking Authority